|
The pros and cons of CTCSS
(Urgent Communications Via Acquire Media NewsEdge) Earlier this week, we began a discussion of CTCSS, an acronym for
Continuous Tone Coded Squelch System. Today we will examine the
practical application of CTCSS. Before the concept of trunked radio
user groups and push-to-talk (PTT) over cellular, many users
purchased portable radios and shared airtime over a given RF
channel, which usually was owned and licensed by a local radio
shop. Plumbers, electricians and livery services all could operate
on the same channel with each company employing a different CTCSS
tone.
This concept commonly was known as a community repeater, with
CTCSS used to separate the various users. This same concept is seen
today in the increasing popularity of the Family Radio Service
(FRS) band. Some FRS radio literature calls these CTCSS tones
“privacy codes,” though there is no encryption employed
and conversations over these radios are overheard simply by
pressing the monitor button. In any event, CTCSS works well in
separating user groups.
It allows users to operate their radios in somewhat RF-noisy
environments that, without CTCSS employed, would cause the radio's
receiver to inadvertently unsquelch, which would annoy the
operator. This is particularly a problem for radio users who
utilize open carrier squelch scan. If the squelch constantly opens
and hangs while the radio is scanning, the user is more prone to
disable the scan function, use scan nuisance delete, or change
channels thereby increasing the likelihood of the user
missing a call.
However, radio administrators must use caution when implementing
CTCSS in high RF-noise and -interference environments, because
while CTCSS allows the receiver to remain quiet, the problems of
channel noise and interference still are present and can affect
adversely the operation of the subscriber's receiver. Additionally,
adding CTCSS to a receiver requires the radio to decode the
received tone. Many radios currently on the market are noticeably
slow to decode lower frequency tones; thus, higher frequency tones
are decoded faster, allowing for a faster receiver response and
minimizing the risk of missed radio traffic. Many of the newer
radios also can receive more than one CTCSS tone to open the
speaker on a given channel.
CTCSS can be used in encode-only mode to provide the subscriber
access to a repeater or network. Some repeaters will pass CTCSS
tones to selectively call individual users, while other repeaters
will re-generate a clean CTCSS tone when they receive a particular
tone. Additionally, administrators can choose to use a separate
CTCSS tone for the repeater input, as opposed to the output, in
order to minimize the possibility of the repeater hearing itself in
high RF-interference environments which happens more often
than realized.
Reverse burst. In a
series of transmissions between a mobile or portable subscriber
unit and the base station or repeater, there normally is a loud
burst of audio at the end of each transmission as the subscriber
unit quits transmitting, but the receiver squelch is still open.
This typically is referred to as a “squelch tail.” In a
series of short transmissions, squelch tail becomes quite
annoying.
Fortunately, the radio equipment manufacturers have devised a
method to eliminate the squelch tail. This is accomplished by
sending the same tone frequency, but 180 degrees out of phase, for
a period of approximately 250 milliseconds upon the release of the
subscriber unit’s PTT button. When the base station or
repeater station senses this reverse burst, it immediately mutes
the receiver audio and there no longer is a squelch tail; instead,
what one experiences is a quiet, abrupt end of the transmission.
Some radios can be set for a 180-degree reverse burst, while others
utilize a 120-degree reverse burst. The latter was an attempt by
one of the major manufacturers to make their radios sound superior
to those of its competitors, but the other manufacturers soon
figured out this scheme and they too made the 120-degree reverse
burst feature available.
Digital coded squelch.
In the 1970s, before there was cellular, trunking, 700 MHz, 800 MHz
and 900 MHz radio systems, all of the land-mobile radio systems
were on low band (30-50 MHz), high band (136-174 MHz) or UHF
(400-470 MHz) frequencies, and these bands were very crowded. As a
result, the 38 CTCSS tones were insufficient to eliminate
interference in the large cities. Motorola then came out with a
digital version of the tones, and there were more than 100 of these
codes. Motorola called this digital private line, or DPL. Because
of patent protection, only Motorola subscriber units could be used
on these systems. Once the patents ran out in the late 1980s or
early 1990s, then the other manufacturers did include the DCS codes
in their radios.
The DCS codes also had the inverted code for each corresponding
main code, and the inverted code was used as the squelch-tail
eliminator on these systems.
Conclusion. CTCSS has
been employed in conventional communications systems for decades
and with modern synthesized radios, there is no longer the need to
add a module for CTCSS encode and decode functionality. While the
concept of CTCSS is not difficult to understand, it can be a great
asset to the radio technician, engineer and end-user if employed
properly. As with any implemented radio feature, ensure that all
your users and those agencies that they may need to communicate
with have the proper CTCSS tones enabled on the proper channels.
For interoperability channels and associated CTCSS tones, a good
resource to reference is the National Interoperability Field Operations
Guide produced by the Department of Homeland Security. Lastly,
ensure that radio technicians are present at interoperability
training exercises to ensure that the proper CTCSS tones and
frequencies are programmed into the respective agencies’
radio gear, so when that emergency need to communicate arises, your
agency will be ready.
Ira Wiesenfeld, P.E., has been
involved with commercial radio systems since 1966, and has
experience with land-mobile-radio, paging and military
communications systems. He holds an FCC general radiotelephone
operator’s license and is the author of Wiring for
Wireless Sites, as well as many
articles in various magazines. Wiesenfeld can be reached atiwiesenfel@aol.com.
Christopher Dalton has
designed, staged and implemented virtually every kind of LMR system
in his two-decade-long career, including conventional, trunked,
simulcast, Project 25, single-site and multisite. He holds an FCC
general radiotelephone operator’s license. Dalton can be
reached atcdalton@fairpoint.net.
© 2012 Penton Media
[ Back To SIP Phones Homepage's Homepage ]
|